Research claim maturity

Defines the progression from sourced idea to reproduced experiment, implementation evidence, preview support, and stable capability.

Research
Last verified
Not verified
Updated
Reading time
1 minutes

Defines the progression from sourced idea to reproduced experiment, implementation evidence, preview support, and stable capability.

Maturity path

  1. Research: sourced question, design, or report.
  2. Proposed: bounded architecture with owner and acceptance criteria.
  3. Experimental: implementation or experiment exists, with known gaps.
  4. Preview: published for limited use with explicit compatibility and support boundaries.
  5. Stable: versioned, tested, documented, supported, and monitored.

Planned and Deprecated describe scheduling or lifecycle, not evidence strength.

Scope

This starter page defines the questions, boundaries, evidence, and failure modes that should be recorded before a capability is presented as supported.

Engineering considerations

  • Identify the source, version, target environment, and owner.
  • Separate observed values from estimates and externally reported values.
  • Record trade-offs, unsupported cases, and fallback behavior.
  • Link performance statements to a compatible benchmark methodology.

Verification questions

  • What exact artifact, revision, backend, and environment were reviewed?
  • Which assumptions could change the result?
  • Which data should be retained so another engineer can reproduce the conclusion?